Paper guideGlossy or matte is the first question most people get asked when they order a print, and it changes the look of an image more than you'd expect. The same file can look punchy and dimensional on one paper and soft and painterly on another. Neither is better. They're different tools.
Here's how the main finishes compare, when to use each, and how they map to the papers we print on at IMPRESO.
01
The three main finishes
Glossy
Glossy paper has a smooth, highly reflective coating, like the surface of a magazine cover or a classic drugstore print.
- Strengths: the deepest blacks and most saturated color of any finish, plus crisp fine detail. Images look sharp and dimensional.
- Weaknesses: strong reflections and glare, shows fingerprints and smudges easily, and can stick to glass if framed without a mat or spacer.
Luster (semi-gloss)
Luster sits between glossy and matte. It has a subtle texture, often described as a fine pebble or "E-surface" finish, that breaks up reflections while keeping much of glossy's color and contrast. Semi-gloss, pearl and satin papers are close relatives.
- Strengths: rich color, deep blacks, far less glare than glossy, and better resistance to fingerprints. It's the standard surface for professional photo labs and portfolio prints.
- Weaknesses: slightly less "pop" than true glossy, and the texture is visible up close under raking light.
Matte
Matte paper has no shine. Fine art matte papers are often made from cotton rag and come in smooth (hot press) or textured (cold press) surfaces.
- Strengths: no glare at all, a soft and tactile look, excellent for black and white, illustration and art reproduction. Doesn't show fingerprints in the same way.
- Weaknesses: blacks are less deep and colors are slightly more muted, because the surface scatters light. The paper is also more delicate and can scuff if handled roughly.
02
Glossy vs luster vs matte compared
| Glossy | Luster / semi-gloss | Matte | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reflection and glare | High | Low to moderate | None |
| Color saturation | Highest | High | Moderate |
| Black depth (Dmax) | Highest | High | Lower |
| Fine detail | Very crisp | Very crisp | Slightly softer |
| Fingerprints | Shows easily | Resists well | Resists smudges, can mark if rubbed |
| Behind glass | Can double up reflections | Works well | Works very well |
| Unframed display | Glare-prone | Good | Excellent |
| Feel | Slick, photographic | Photographic, satin | Paper-like, artistic |
| Best for | Vivid color, small prints held in hand | Most photography | Art, B&W, illustration, soft or moody images |
03
What Dmax and color gamut mean
Two terms come up a lot when people compare papers.
- Dmax is the maximum density, or how dark the darkest black the paper can show. Higher Dmax means richer shadows and more perceived contrast. Glossy and luster papers have higher Dmax because their smooth coatings keep ink on the surface and reflect light cleanly.
- Color gamut is the range of colors a paper and ink combination can reproduce. Coated photo papers hold a wider gamut, especially in saturated blues, greens and reds. Matte cotton papers have a slightly smaller gamut, which is why a bright sunset can look calmer on matte.
On matte paper, light scatters off the surface fibers and lifts the blacks a little. That's not a defect. It's what gives matte prints their soft, painterly quality.
04
Glare and where the print will hang
Think about the room before you pick a finish.
- Bright room, lots of windows, or a spot facing a light source: matte or luster. Glossy will reflect the window back at you for part of the day.
- Hallway, gallery lighting, or controlled light: luster or glossy can show off their color without much glare.
- Unframed, leaned on a shelf or pinned to a wall: matte looks great and won't catch light. Luster also works.
05
Framing behind glass
Once a print goes behind glass or acrylic, the glazing adds its own reflection on top of the paper's. That changes the calculation.
- Matte under glass gives you one reflective surface instead of two. Many framers recommend it for that reason.
- Luster under glass frames beautifully and is the common choice for framed photography.
- Glossy under glass stacks two shiny surfaces, which can look busy. Use a mat or spacers so the print never touches the glass, since glossy coatings can stick to glazing over time in humid conditions.
If glare is a concern, anti-reflective glass helps more than any paper choice, but it costs more.
06
Fingerprints and handling
If people will hold the print, as with gifts, portfolios or prints handed around at an event, finish matters.
- Glossy shows every fingerprint.
- Luster hides them well and can be handled casually.
- Matte cotton papers don't smudge like glossy, but oils and rubbing can mark the surface, so handle by the edges or with cotton gloves.
07
Which finish is right for your image?
Choose luster or glossy if:
- It's a color photograph where saturation and contrast are the point: landscapes, product shots, street photography, travel.
- You want deep, inky shadows.
- It's a portfolio or print people will handle.
Choose matte if:
- It's a reproduction of a painting, drawing or illustration.
- It's black and white with a soft, classic feel, or a moody, low-contrast image.
- It will hang in a bright room or under glass where reflections would bother you.
- You want the print to feel like a piece of art paper rather than a photograph.
Choose textured matte if:
- It's a reproduction of a watercolor, gouache or acrylic painting and you want the paper texture to echo the original.
08
How this maps to IMPRESO papers
We print every order as a giclée on Epson Signature Worthy papers with Epson UltraChrome HDR pigment inks, then check each print by hand at our studio in Ridgewood, Queens. Our lineup is one photographic semi-gloss surface and two fine art matte surfaces.
Ultra Premium Luster: our pick for photography
A semi-gloss, E-surface photo paper with high Dmax and a vibrant color gamut. It gives you nearly all of glossy's punch with much less glare and much better fingerprint resistance. If you're printing photographs and aren't sure, start here.
Hot Press Bright / Natural: smooth matte cotton
A smooth, 100% cotton rag, acid-free paper. It holds fine detail cleanly and is our go-to for illustration, drawing and fine art reproduction. It's also a lovely choice for black and white or quiet, minimal photographs. Bright has a cleaner white base, Natural a warmer one.
Cold Press Bright / Natural: textured matte cotton
A textured 100% cotton rag, acid-free paper with a visible tooth. It's made for painting reproductions, where the surface texture adds to the feel of the original. Fine detail is softened slightly by the texture, so it's less suited to crisp photographs.
| Your image | Our recommendation |
|---|---|
| Color photography | Ultra Premium Luster |
| Black and white photography | Ultra Premium Luster for contrast, Hot Press for a softer feel |
| Illustration, drawing, digital art | Hot Press |
| Painting reproduction | Cold Press, or Hot Press for smooth originals |
| Moody, low-contrast photos | Hot Press |
You can compare prices for each paper and size on our pricing page. Luster starts at $30 for an 8×10, Hot Press at $35 and Cold Press at $40.
09
Still not sure? Order a proof
The honest answer is that some images could go either way, and seeing them on paper settles it fast. We offer an 8×10 proof print for $30, credited to your order, so you can check paper and color before committing to a large print. You can add it when you build your print.
Pick your finish
Upload your file, choose Luster, Hot Press or Cold Press, and our free file check will show the resolution and crop for your size. There's no minimum order and standard turnaround is 3 to 5 business days, with free pickup in Ridgewood or shipping. Start your print order and we'll print it the way it was meant to look.
Build your print → See giclée printing →More guides
